--- title: PPA Billing Calculation & 3-Tier Approval Guide description: Detailed guide to PEA TOU billing calculations, Bangkok period boundaries, Ft rate enforcement, worked math examples, 3-tier SoD approval, PDF exports, and tariff comparison. --- ::: warning UAT release This guide describes the upcoming portal update. Some screens or actions may differ in the current UAT portal. ::: # PPA Billing Calculation & 3-Tier Approval Guide The WattDee billing module (`/billing`) calculates Private Solar PPA monthly invoices from 15-minute smart meter telemetry under Thailand's Provincial Electricity Authority (PEA) Time-of-Use (TOU) tariff structure, protected by a 3-tier verification and approval workflow (**Draft → Checked → Approved**) with full audit traceability and Segregation of Duties (SoD). ::: info Access to `/billing` Opening **PPA Billing & Invoicing** requires the `invoice.view` capability (see [Roles and Permissions](./01-roles-and-permissions)): - **Developer & Platform Staff** (`Platform ADMIN`, `Developer ADMIN`, `SERVICE`, `ACCOUNTING`): Access the full billing workspace and 3-tier approval controls. - **Customer / Off-Taker Users** (`Customer ADMIN`, `CUSTOMER`): Automatically routed to the dedicated Customer Billing view showing **only `APPROVED` invoices** (see the [Customer Portal Guide](./07-customer-portal-guide)). - **`OPERATOR` and `READER` roles**: Do **not** hold `invoice.view`. Navigating directly to `/billing` displays an **`AccessDenied`** screen. ::: --- ## 1. Billing Workspace Views: Table vs. Stage Board From `/billing`, you can manage monthly invoicing across all active sites using two synchronized views: ### Top Toolbar & Filters 1. **Billing period**: Select the target **Month** and **Year**. The subtitle shows the exact calendar dates covered based on the site's cut-off day (e.g., `1 Oct – 31 Oct`, or `25 Sep – 24 Oct` when `billingCycleDay = 25`). 2. **Search**: Filter by site name, site code, customer company name, or invoice number. 3. **Invoice status filter**: - **All stages** - **1. Missing bills**: Active sites without a live invoice for the selected period. - **2. Draft**: Calculated and persisted; awaiting Stage 2 technical review. - **3. Checked**: Technically verified by Service; awaiting Stage 3 accounting sign-off. - **4. Approved**: Finalized with an Invoice Reference Code and published to the Customer Portal. - **5. Voided**: Canceled (`REJECTED`) invoices retained for audit history; eligible for replacement reissue. 4. **More tools**: Opens **Compare PPA rate with utility** (Tariff Savings Comparison) and **Create bill with incomplete meter data** (Fallback billing). ### View 1: Table View The Table view groups sites by customer company (collapsible groups with per-stage counts) and supports multi-select checkboxes for batch invoice generation and batch Stage 3 approval. ![Monthly billing table view showing grouped customer companies, invoice statuses, and totals](/screenshots/en/13-billing-overview-table.png) ### View 2: 5-Stage Kanban Board (`Stage board`) Switch the view toggle to **Stage board** and pick a customer company (`บริษัทลูกค้า` / Customer company) to display the 5 workflow columns: 1. **1. Missing (`รอสร้างบิล`)**: No bill calculated for this period yet. 2. **2. Draft (`แบบร่าง`)**: Awaiting Stage 2 Service verification. 3. **3. Checked (`ตรวจแล้ว`)**: Awaiting Stage 3 Accounting approval. 4. **4. Approved (`อนุมัติแล้ว`)**: Issued and awaiting customer payment/countersignature. 5. **5. Voided (`ยกเลิกแล้ว`)**: Canceled; ready to reissue a replacement. Click any card to open the Invoice Detail dialog, drag empty board space to pan horizontally, or drag cards between columns (3-tier rules are enforced: for instance, you cannot drag directly from `Draft` to `Approved` without passing `Checked`). ![5-stage Kanban billing board showing workflow columns and invoice cards](/screenshots/en/14-billing-kanban-board.png) --- ## 2. Billing Window, Bangkok Timezone (UTC+7), and Open-Period Guard To ensure interval totals agree with physical meter end-of-month register resets, every billing window is evaluated on **`Asia/Bangkok` (`UTC+7`)** midnight (Thailand has no daylight saving time): - **Standard calendar cut-off (`billingCycleDay = 1`)**: Billing month `YYYY-MM` runs from `YYYY-MM-01 00:00:00+07:00` (inclusive) to the `1st of the following month 00:00:00+07:00` (exclusive). - **Cross-month cut-off (`billingCycleDay = 2..28`)**: For example, with `cycleDay = 25`, billing month `2026-10` covers `2026-09-25 00:00:00+07:00` (inclusive) to `2026-10-25 00:00:00+07:00` (exclusive). - **First invoice for newly commissioned sites (`activeFrom`)**: When every active meter on a site was commissioned (`activeFrom`) inside the billing cycle, the invoice's `billingPeriodStart` starts at the earliest meter's `activeFrom` timestamp so the first invoice reflects true operating days and Stage 2 coverage checks do not penalize pre-commissioning days. - **Payment due date (`dueDate`)**: Calculated as `paymentTermDays` (default `30` days) after the cut-off date at `23:59:59+07:00` (e.g., `2026-10` cut on the 25th with 30-day terms is due on `24 Nov`). ::: warning Open-Period Guard (BL-1) By default, invoices can only be generated **after the billing period has ended** (`endDate <= now`): - Attempting to bill a period that has not started yet is rejected with HTTP **`422`**. - Attempting to bill an ongoing period before its cut-off date is rejected with HTTP **`422`**, unless confirmed by a user holding **`invoice.issueEarly`** (`Developer ADMIN` or `Platform ADMIN`) through the early-issuance confirmation dialog showing elapsed vs. total period days (e.g., `18/31 days`). ::: --- ## 3. Mandatory Ft Rate Verification & Public Holiday Calendar ### 3.1 Verifying the Monthly Ft Rate Because the Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC) Fuel Adjustment Tariff (**Ft**) is a system-wide regulatory parameter, only a **Platform Administrator** (`ftrate.write`) can configure or update it: 1. If the selected month has no verified Ft rate on record, a warning banner (**Ft verification required**) appears at the top of `/billing`. 2. Click **Verify Ft rate** (or open **Settings → Billing & tariffs**). 3. Verify the target `YYYY-MM` billing month and enter the declared **Ft rate (THB/kWh)** between `-2.0000` and `10.0000`. (If unconfigured, the input starts blank rather than auto-filling an unverified value; the latest configured month is shown below as reference only.) 4. Click **Confirm** to save. ::: danger Mandatory Ft Refusal (`422`) & Period Lock - Both preview calculations and invoice generation **refuse with HTTP `422`** if no Ft rate exists for `YYYY-MM`. The billing engine never invents a fallback Ft rate for real invoices. - Once any invoice for a billing month reaches `CHECKED` or `APPROVED`, the Ft rate for that month is **locked** and cannot be modified. ::: ### 3.2 Public Holiday Calendar Platform Administrators manage official Thai public holidays under **Settings → Holidays** (supporting annual PEA preset auto-fill as well as manual entries). Dates are evaluated in `Asia/Bangkok` calendar dates (`YYYY-MM-DD`) so official holidays, including Songkran and substitution holidays, always bill at the `Holiday Off-Peak` rate. --- ## 4. TOU Billing Formulas, Rounding Rules & Worked Examples ### 4.1 Official PEA TOU Schedule (Asia/Bangkok UTC+7) | TOU Period | Days | Time Window (24-Hour) | Applied Contract Rate | | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | | **On-Peak** | Monday – Friday | `09:00:00 – 21:59:59` | Contract On-Peak Rate | | **Off-Peak** | Monday – Friday | `22:00:00 – 08:59:59` | Contract Off-Peak Rate | | **Holiday & Weekend Off-Peak** | Saturday, Sunday & Official Public Holidays | `00:00:00 – 23:59:59` | **Contract Off-Peak Rate** | ### 4.2 Multi-Meter & Mid-Cycle Swap Aggregation 1. **Strict Active-Window Clipping**: Intervals from each meter are clipped to `[activeFrom, activeTo)` so bench-test packets or post-decommission readings never leak into billing. 2. **Total Energy**: Sum of scaled kWh across all contributing active meters. 3. **Site Concurrent Peak Demand (`demandPeakKw`)**: At every 15-minute timestamp `t`, the engine sums active power `kW` across all active meters simultaneously (`max_t Σ P_m(t)`). For example, if Meter A draws 400 kW while Meter B draws 1,600 kW in the same 15-minute slot, site Peak Demand is `2,000.000 kW`. `demandOnPeakKw` and `demandOffPeakKw` are also recorded for reference, while any demand charge bills on overall `demandPeakKw`. 4. **Meter Replacement Schedule Annex**: Whenever >1 meter contributes during a billing period, `meterId` on the invoice header is `null` and Page 2 of the PDF automatically attaches the **Attached Meter Replacement Schedule** showing per-meter active dates, kWh, peak kW, and interval counts. ### 4.3 Step-by-Step Rounding & Formulas (`ROUND_HALF_UP`) All calculations execute in arbitrary-precision decimal arithmetic (`BigNumber`) and round **half-up at every step** so printed invoice lines always reconcile to the exact satang (`0.01 THB`): 1. **Quantities**: - `energyOnPeakKwh`, `energyOffPeakKwh`, and `energyHolidayOffPeakKwh` are each rounded to **2 decimal places** (default; configurable 0–4). - `totalEnergyKwh` is the exact sum of the three printed rounded energy lines. - `demandPeakKw` and `peakKvar` are rounded to **3 decimal places**. 2. **Base Energy & Demand Charges**: - `onPeakAmount` = `round_2(energyOnPeakKwh × onPeakRate)` - `offPeakAmount` = `round_2(energyOffPeakKwh × offPeakRate)` - `holidayOffPeakAmount` = `round_2(energyHolidayOffPeakKwh × offPeakRate)` - `baseEnergyAmountThb` = `onPeakAmount + offPeakAmount + holidayOffPeakAmount` - `demandAmountThb` = `round_2(demandPeakKw × demandRateKw)` (`0.00` for energy-only Solar PPAs) 3. **Float Tariff (Ft)**: - `ftTotalAmountThb` = `round_2(totalEnergyKwh × ftRateThb)` 4. **Contract Discount**: - Eligible when `discountPercent > 0` and the billing month falls within `[discountStartDate, discountExpiryDate]`. - Applied **strictly to `(Base Energy + Ft)`**, never to Demand Charge or Power Factor Penalty: - `discountAmountThb` = `round_2((baseEnergyAmountThb + ftTotalAmountThb) × (discountPercent / 100))` 5. **Optional Power Factor (PF) Penalty**: - Evaluated only when `pfPenaltyEnabled = true`, `demandPeakKw > 0`, and `peakKvar > 0`. - At default `pfThreshold = 0.85`, `tan(arccos(0.85)) = 0.6197`. - `allowanceKvar = demandPeakKw × tanPhi`. - If `peakKvar > allowanceKvar`: `excessKvar = round_2(peakKvar - allowanceKvar)` and `pfPenaltyAmountThb = round_2(excessKvar × pfPenaltyRateThb)` (default `56.07 THB/kVAR`). 6. **Net Subtotal, 7% VAT & Total Payable**: - `netSubtotal` = `baseEnergyAmountThb + ftTotalAmountThb - discountAmountThb + demandAmountThb + pfPenaltyAmountThb` - `vatAmountThb` = `round_2(netSubtotal × 0.07)` - `totalPayableThb` = `netSubtotal + vatAmountThb` ### 4.4 Worked Calculation Examples #### Example 1: Standard Energy-Only Solar PPA (15% Discount, No Demand Charge) Suppose for billing month `2026-10`: - **On-Peak Energy**: `10,000.00 kWh` @ `4.1839 THB/kWh` - **Off-Peak Energy**: `5,000.00 kWh` @ `2.6037 THB/kWh` - **Holiday Off-Peak Energy**: `2,000.00 kWh` @ `2.6037 THB/kWh` - **Peak Demand**: `120.000 kW` @ `0.0000 THB/kW` | PF Penalty disabled - **Ft Rate**: `0.3972 THB/kWh` | **PPA Discount**: `15.00%` | Step | Line Item | Calculation & Half-Up Rounding | Amount (THB) | | :--- | :--- | :--- | ---: | | 1 | On-Peak Energy Charge | `10,000.00 × 4.1839 = 41,839.00` | `41,839.00` | | 2 | Off-Peak Energy Charge | `5,000.00 × 2.6037 = 13,018.50` | `13,018.50` | | 3 | Holiday Off-Peak Charge | `2,000.00 × 2.6037 = 5,207.40` | `5,207.40` | | 4 | **Base Energy Subtotal** | `41,839.00 + 13,018.50 + 5,207.40` | **`60,064.90`** | | 5 | **Ft Surcharge (`17,000.00 kWh`)** | `17,000.00 × 0.3972 = 6,752.40` | **`6,752.40`** | | 6 | Energy + Ft (Discount Base) | `60,064.90 + 6,752.40` | `66,817.30` | | 7 | **Contract Discount (`15.00%`)** | `66,817.30 × 0.15 = 10,022.595` (half-up) | **`-10,022.60`** | | 8 | **Net Subtotal before VAT** | `66,817.30 - 10,022.60` | **`56,794.70`** | | 9 | **VAT (7.00%)** | `56,794.70 × 0.07 = 3,975.629` (half-up) | **`3,975.63`** | | 10 | **Total Payable** | `56,794.70 + 3,975.63` | **`60,770.33`** | #### Example 2: Contract with Demand Charge & Power Factor Penalty Using the same energy and Ft figures as Example 1, plus: - **Peak Demand**: `120.000 kW` @ `132.9300 THB/kW` - **Peak kVAR**: `100.000 kVAR` (PF threshold `0.85`, penalty rate `56.07 THB/kVAR`) 1. **PPA Discount (15%)** remains **`-10,022.60 THB`** because the discount applies only to `(Base Energy + Ft)`. 2. **Peak Demand Charge**: `120.000 × 132.9300` = **`15,951.60 THB`**. 3. **PF Penalty**: - Reactive allowance (`tanPhi = 0.6197`): `120.000 × 0.6197 = 74.364 kVAR` - Excess kVAR: `round_2(100.000 - 74.364) = 25.64 kVAR` - Penalty: `round_2(25.64 × 56.07) = round_2(1,437.6348)` = **`1,437.63 THB`** 4. **Net Subtotal before VAT**: `60,064.90 + 6,752.40 - 10,022.60 + 15,951.60 + 1,437.63` = **`74,183.93 THB`** 5. **VAT (7.00%)**: `round_2(74,183.93 × 0.07) = round_2(5,192.8751)` = **`5,192.88 THB`** 6. **Total Payable**: `74,183.93 + 5,192.88` = **`79,376.81 THB`** --- ## 5. Stage 1: Generating Draft Invoices & Fallback Modes Required capability: `invoice.generate` (`Developer ADMIN`, `Developer ACCOUNTING`, `Platform ADMIN`). ### Single or Batch Invoice Generation 1. Select the billing month and year, ensuring the monthly Ft rate has been verified. 2. **Single site**: Click **Create bill (`สร้างบิล`)** or **Reissue (`ออกบิลใหม่`)** on the table row or Kanban card. 3. **Batch generation**: Check multiple sites in **Missing** or **Voided** state (or select an entire company group), click **Create X bills** in the floating action bar, review the list in the confirmation dialog, and confirm. ![Batch invoice generation confirmation modal showing selected sites and companies](/screenshots/en/15-billing-generate-modal.png) ::: tip Automatic Backfill Refresh & Recalculation Rules - Before calculating an `AUTO` invoice, the server automatically re-projects `hes.meter_readings` across the entire billing window (`refreshProjection`) so any telemetry recovered after an outage is included. - Recalculating an existing `DRAFT` or `CHECKED` invoice preserves its `invoiceNumber`, increments `revision`, resets status to `DRAFT` (requiring a fresh Stage 2 check), and never alters an `APPROVED` invoice. - Only **`DRAFT`** invoices can be deleted (**Delete draft**); `CHECKED`, `APPROVED`, and `REJECTED` invoices must use **Void** to preserve the audit trail. ::: ### Incomplete Meter Data Fallback (`ROLLING_AVG` / `MANUAL`) If a meter experienced a prolonged outage: 1. Click **More tools → Create bill with incomplete meter data**. 2. Pick the **Site** and choose a calculation mode: - **`ROLLING_AVG`**: Averages On-Peak, Off-Peak, Holiday, Peak Demand kW, and Peak kVAR from up to the 3 most recent non-voided invoices. - **`MANUAL`**: Enter on-site meter readings directly (`On-Peak kWh`, `Off-Peak kWh`, `Holiday kWh`, `Peak kW`, `Peak kVAR`). - **`AUTO`**: Standard 15-minute interval projection. 3. Click **Calculate & create invoice** to save as `DRAFT`. --- ## 6. Stage 2: Technical Service Verification (`DRAFT → CHECKED`) Required capability: `invoice.check` (`Developer ADMIN`, `Developer SERVICE`, `Platform ADMIN`). Click a `DRAFT` card or row to inspect its financial, TOU telemetry, and audit details, then click **Check bill (`ตรวจบิล`)**. ![Invoice detail dialog in DRAFT status showing TOU breakdown and technical review CTA](/screenshots/en/16-billing-invoice-detail-draft.png) Transitioning to `CHECKED` executes the 6-point **Stage 2 Telemetry & Multiplier Audit (`verifyInvoiceTelemetry`)**: 1. **CT/VT Multiplier & Reading Side**: Verifies `readingSide` is `PRIMARY` or `SECONDARY` (never `UNKNOWN`), HES meter identity is verified, multiplier is within `[0.001, 1000000]`, and `multiplierRatio` matches `(CT × VT)` within **5%**. 2. **15-Minute Telemetry Coverage**: Compares actual vs. expected intervals (`>= 95%` PASSED; `< 95%` or `< 80%` WARNING; `0` intervals FAILED). 3. **Meter Swap Continuity**: Confirms zero overlapping interval timestamps between retired (`activeTo`) and replacement meters. 4. **Physical Sanity**: Flags negative active energy intervals (`FAILED`) or Peak Demand > `125%` of plant rated `kWp` (`WARNING`). 5. **Register Reconciliation**: Compares summed 15-minute kWh against the meter's cumulative register delta over the period and counts `ESTIMATED` outage-gap intervals. 6. **HES Interval Quality** (when interval confirmation rules or `PLAUSIBILITY_GUARD` flags apply): Reports intervals requiring manual review before approval. If any critical check is `FAILED`, transition to `CHECKED` is blocked (`400`). Non-critical observations (`WARNING`) are recorded on the audit report and still allow checking. Moving to `CHECKED` also **locks the billing month** (`periodLock`) so subsequent late telemetry is routed to `late_intervals` rather than mutating the audited bill (see [Locked Periods & Late Intervals](./08-troubleshooting-faq)). --- ## 7. Stage 3: Accounting Final Approval (`CHECKED → APPROVED`) Required capability: `invoice.approve` (`Developer ADMIN`, `Developer ACCOUNTING`, `Platform ADMIN`). ![Invoice detail dialog in CHECKED status ready for Accounting final approval](/screenshots/en/17-billing-invoice-detail-checked.png) 1. Review the `CHECKED` invoice and Stage 2 audit report (`View verification report`). 2. Click **Sign & Approve (`ลงนามอนุมัติ`)** (or batch-select multiple `CHECKED` invoices). 3. Verify the site, invoice number, billing month, and Total Payable in the **Final Approval** modal, then click **Confirm & Apply Digital Signature**. ### Inviolable Stage 3 Governance Rules - **No Direct Jump**: Invoices cannot skip from `DRAFT` directly to `APPROVED`; Stage 2 `CHECKED` is mandatory. - **Segregation of Duties (`checker ≠ approver`)**: The user who approves (`APPROVED`) **cannot be the same user** who performed Stage 2 verification (`checkedByServiceUserId`), even if that user holds an `ADMIN` role. In the UI, the checker sees a **`SoD restriction`** (`ติดเงื่อนไข SoD`) shield badge instead of the approve button. - **Invoice Reference Code (`รหัสอ้างอิงใบแจ้งหนี้`)**: Approval generates a SHA-256 hash formatted as `SIG_AVG_<32_HEX_CHARS>` from `invoiceNumber|totalPayableThb|billingMonth|checkedByServiceUserId`, printed on the PDF audit strip as **`Invoice reference code`** (`รหัสอ้างอิงใบแจ้งหนี้` in the UI, replacing the legacy electronic certification wording). - **`issuedSnapshot`**: At approval time, the seller, buyer, project, and default bank account details are frozen in `issued_snapshot` so later settings updates never alter historical tax invoices. - **Immutability & Customer Publication**: The invoice is locked permanently and immediately visible in the [Customer Portal](./07-customer-portal-guide). --- ## 8. PDF Preview, Exports, Voiding, Payment & Email Delivery ### 8.1 PDF Preview & Exports (`PDF` / `Billing Notice` / `Excel` / `Word`) Click **Preview PDF (`พรีวิว PDF`)** to open the live A4 document viewer: ![Approved invoice details with the Preview PDF action at the bottom](/screenshots/en/18-billing-invoice-pdf-preview.png) - **Status Watermarks**: `DRAFT` and `CHECKED` documents display a diagonal **`ร่าง – ยังไม่อนุมัติ / DRAFT – NOT APPROVED`** watermark; voided documents display **`ยกเลิก / VOID`**; only `APPROVED` documents carry **`ต้นฉบับ / Original`**. - **System vs. Signed PDF Toggle**: Once the customer uploads a countersigned PDF, switch between **System PDF** and **Signed PDF** right inside the preview dialog. - **Private Signature Previews**: Organization signatory images and customer countersignature images are stored privately (`private/signatures/...`) and retrieved strictly through authenticated endpoints (`/api/organizations/:id/signature` and `/api/invoices/:id/customer-signature` with `Cache-Control: private, no-store`), never exposed via public URLs. - **Legal Identity Guard (`422`)**: Exporting documents refuses with `422` if either seller or buyer lacks a company name, valid 13-digit Tax ID, or address. - **Export Formats**: Official bilingual A4 **PDF** (with Annex Page 2 for multi-meter sites), **Billing Notice PDF (`ใบวางบิล`)** (single or consolidated), multi-sheet **Excel (`.xlsx`)** with 15-min interval load curves, and **Word (`.docx`)** executive summary. ### 8.2 Voiding (`REJECTED`) & Reissuing If a `DRAFT`, `CHECKED`, or `APPROVED` invoice must be canceled (requires `invoice.void`): 1. Open the row `⋮` menu (or card icon) and select **Void (`ยกเลิกบิล`)**. 2. Enter a mandatory **cancellation reason** (minimum 3 characters) and confirm. 3. The invoice transitions permanently to **`REJECTED`** (`voidedAt`, `voidedByUserId`, `voidReason` preserved), any pending **`late_intervals`** for that period are replayed into `load_profile_15min` in the same transaction, and you can immediately click **Reissue (`ออกบิลใหม่`)** to generate a new replacement invoice with the next running number. ### 8.3 Payment Tracking & Email Dispatch - **Payment Status**: Click the payment status pill (`Unpaid`, `Paid`, `Partial`, `Overdue`) on any row or card to record paid amount, due date, and transfer/receipt reference. - **Email Dispatch**: Use `⋮ → Send email` to dispatch the invoice PDF notification to the off-taker's accounting contact. --- ## 9. Tariff Savings Comparison & Parallel Run Diagnostics ### 9.1 Tariff Savings Comparison (`Compare PPA rate with utility`) 1. Open **More tools → Compare PPA rate with utility**. 2. Choose a site for the active billing month. The report computes three side-by-side totals from the exact same interval stream: - **PPA Contract**: Actual contracted TOU rates and PPA discount. - **PEA Standard TOU**: `0%` discount benchmark. - **Fixed Flat Rate Benchmark**: Midpoint average of On-Peak and Off-Peak rates (`0%` discount, no demand charge). 3. Review net THB savings and `%` savings versus PEA. ::: warning `0.3972` Ft Fallback Warning Banner If the selected `YYYY-MM` billing month has **no configured Ft rate** in the database (`ftRateIsFallback = true`), Tariff Savings Comparison uses a provisional **`0.3972 THB/kWh`** fallback rate so teams can preview estimated savings, and displays a yellow warning banner: > *"Month YYYY-MM has no Ft rate configured: using fallback 0.3972 THB/kWh for preliminary comparison."* Unlike comparison previews, actual invoice calculation and generation strictly refuse with `422` until a verified Ft rate is saved. ::: ![Tariff savings comparison modal comparing PPA Contract vs PEA Standard TOU with the 0.3972 Ft fallback banner](/screenshots/en/19-billing-tariff-comparison.png) ### 9.2 Parallel Run (`invoice.compare`) Users with `invoice.compare` can open `⋮ → Compare meter data` (`เทียบข้อมูลมิเตอร์`) to inspect a read-only comparison between bills computed from cumulative **readings projection** versus direct **HES 15-minute intervals**, broken down per meter and TOU band along with any unconfirmed or flagged intervals.